=====
From trothgard@citywidesoftware.com:
I like the wood paneling on the floor.  The green stand under the globe seemeda
bit weird, especially for an oldish looking globe.  The book case is neat, but
I would've liked to have seen a little variance in the sizes of the books in
poth thickness and height.  Also the wall texture behind the man seems a bit
off.  The lighting and the tablecloth are supurb :)

=====
From cly@u.arizona.edu:
Your globe, sculpture and the man looks great. I suggest making the knight's
suit more metallic, put some shine into it. I also think that you need to work
on face of the cat. It does not look like a cat. Also, a great idea is to make
light reflect off of particle when the light come from the window. I'm not sure
what the exact terminology is, but I know you can do it. This will make it
realistic.




=====
From robbert@mintec.ca:
The main character doesn't look too relaxed.  She's posing in her sleep? :) 
Shin and shirt seems plasticy.  texture on the cat's back isn't that nicely
lined up.
=====
From pokorny@attglobal.net:
Several of the image submitted in this round would work for the current
lonliness topic.  This image I wish we could somehow move into the
current round.  I feel it is perfect for the lonliness round. But,
dreaming it is. I very much like the cat, table cloth, flooring and
the painting and how the figure in it is aligned somewhat with the
thinking man figure. A few items could have been stronger. Namely the
green support at the bottom of the stand holding the globe looks out
of place. The night looks too real to be a suit of armor. The books in
the book shelf are too much alike and what differences there are have
be mixed too much. When books are alike it usually means they are a set
of some sort and usually stacked together. The wood grain for the table
looks like it was applied to the table as a whole instead of each leg.

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
The lighting works well here, and I like the bookshelf.  
The tablecloth seems a bit rigid and symmetrical, 
although the folds look good.  The wood texture on the 
table could use some work, I think.

=====
From lrwii@joplin.com:
Like the lighting and the composition. The cats head 
looks funky.