===== From Kzerphii.Toomk@Wanadoo.fr: Nice light and tower. Freud will explain the scene... ;-) ===== From rgow@lanset.com: Nice image. Water & media look good. Tower looks too clean for an old ruin. ===== From hildurka@simnet.is: Nice image. The good old concept of what is lurking beneath the surface is a classical one. Lot of fairy tale in this one. Good work. ===== From somers@w-link.net: the water needs more action/ripples. ===== From pbrasolin@yahoo.it: A basic image with some nice particulars. PB ===== From info@michaelscholz.de: Interesting. ===== From selsek@fnac.net: Les fant_mes ne sont pas tr_s visibles. Avec ce genre de ciel, tu ne devrais pas avoir un tel _clairage, utilise plut_t la radiosit_. R_p_ter les serpents n'est pas forc_ment une bonne id_e... Tu aurais pu _viter les sonettes aux serpents... ===== From the_dark_allies@hotmail.com: Quite a strange scene. I was not sure at first what the ghosts were. Perhaps some more tweaking on them will prevent this problem with others in the future. ===== From zio_tom78@hotmail.com: Your images have an unique feeling: I can recognize them at the first sight. I've always got a sense of "mistery" in them, so I am not surprised to discover you joined this round. ===== From p_chan@shaw.ca: The colour scheme works well in this image. Perhaps a full moon in the night sky would help enhance the mood of this image. Also, one thing that is missing is some kind of disturbance in the water where the monsters are (splash or a wake). ===== From emediez@emediez.com: The scene needs strenght in textures and lights. ===== From glenn@mccarters.net: Ok, not a bad image. Can you find a more interesting viewpoint instead = of having the tower dead-center and the camera point exactly towards the = horizon? Maybe have the tower off to the right, and the monsters = approaching from the left. Good texture work and intriguing lighting. ===== From file: Those snakes look like they are doing it under water. But I'm sure that wasn't what you were thinking when you made the pick, COUGHCOUGHYEAHRIGHT Notable for originality ===== From file: The idea is good, but the actual execution lets the image down. I would definitely change the background mountains, and give them a landscape texture. By spending a little more time on the background, it helps to promote the foreground and the picture as a whole.