===== From jminner@sc.rr.com: Love the texture used on the cross, very well done. The sky could use a little work. ===== From ph.gibone@wanadoo.fr: Nice Celtic cross ===== From rgow@lanset.com: Good concept and good modeling. Not sure about your lighting, seems odd there are no shadows. ===== From pmccombs@xmission.com: The yellow leaves provide some good contrast. Things look a bit too "mapped", so I would say work on the textures a little more. I think you could make the lighting a little more interesting too. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: The concept was good. The artistic and technical merit were rated less because the image had a 2D look and feel to it. Perhaps it needed shadows cast on the ground plane. The structures needed to be represented in a more symbolic way to be consistent with the ground plane. ===== From kingofmycastle@gmx.net: Nice textures. I like the cross and the sky. But what I really miss are shadows, it looks to plain. ===== From hildurka@simnet.is: Lots of good details and great textures. Except for the one for oil spots, it far too regular to represent dirt in any form, looks more like a carpet or cloth.