=====
From simplepsy@aol.com:
Great meodeling and use of heightfields and procedural textures. 
Something bothered me about the right hand side of the table, and only upon
reading the description did I work out what it was... The use of a spotlight to
fill has produced a bright spot on the corner of the album. Looks a little out
of place but could be fixed by adjusting the brightness a few percent. 
The only other problem I see is the metal material on the lamp, too shiney.
Never use 100% values...always question values above 90%, espectaly for difuse,
transparancy and reflect. If the software supports blurring, use it. 
V. good.  

=====
From rgow@lanset.com:
Great job!  Looks like the brownie I had as a kid, except mine was (strangely
enough) brown. Has a slightly grainy look, not sure if that's intentional, or
the AA.

=====
From uglycasanova420@hotmail.com:
Awsome, I love it one of the best still image I have come across today.

=====
From terraform@upnaway.com:
Good image. nice effects and composition,
Some of the objects appear to be floating and this may be due to the area
light.
Nice use of CSG good to see no modellers used for this one.

=====
From emediez@emediez.com:

Exquisite image.
=====
From marlo.steed@uleth.ca:
This image is stunning and the concept is represented well.  Attention to detail
really makes this come alive.  The lighting seems a bit odd but that is a small
critique to an otherwise good image.

=====
From file:
good placement and photo is a nice touch on the table. I like the concept you
were able to convey. Lamp seems a little reflective.
Notable for composition, originality, modelling, lighting, textures