===== From tom@ringard.org: Very realistic and funny image but... How did you realize it? I can't rate it! ===== From noe.falzon@tiscali.fr: Please write more info about your picture. We can't know if you made the glass and the beer, or if you took it directly from the web... ===== From Knight-Graphics@earthlink.net: Great render, looks like a photo! ===== From jminner@sc.rr.com: Mmmmmmm...Beer!!! ===== From simplepsy@aol.com: Amazing image. A true testiment to 3DSMax and brazil. Nice use of caustics. ===== From rgow@lanset.com: This is the best of your several submissions, but not bothering to give any info on any of them lowers your score, especially as they appear to be in violation of the rule regarding not using already existing images. ===== From terraform@upnaway.com: Very realistic, and i like the focal blur. well done ===== From skirsch@comcast.net: Looks good enough to drink! ===== From ruy@hipernet.com.br: Great invention indeed! And a superb image! ===== From corvus@onewhiteraven.com: the beer is GREAT ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Not much to say here. Your attention to realistic detail is incredible. I am not sure beer would be my idea of a great invention but the image is great. ===== From file: Notable for textures ===== From file: I again do not believe this is anything more than a doctored photo. See the Mclaren F1 entry for further explanation. The lighting out of the bottom of the glass is perfect. The bubbles are perfect. The glass is perfect. The entire scene is too perfect.