===== From tom@ringard.org: There is many parts of your image I really like. The best idea of this round, for me. But I don't like the whole image. Too complex to see ? Too many details who disturbing the concept ? Or a bad centring ? I don't know. It's your first entry so... it is very encouraging for the continuation. ===== From Knight-Graphics@earthlink.net: Lighting, shadows, reflections, and DOF are great! ===== From rgow@lanset.com: Great job on the clutter! Floodlamps look a bit squashed. ===== From corvus@onewhiteraven.com: intriguing. Raven is reminiscent of Gilles Tran's "Wet Bird" (see Povray Hall of Fame) ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: The concept works nicely. However the eye is torn between the competing elements. It is like there are two images in one. Perhaps that is what you were after but I found it a bit distracting - perhaps it is that I had to scroll to see the entire image....(and I have a large monitor).