===== From helene.dumur@free.fr: Yes I do, it is a great picture ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Great concept. The image has a nice feel to it - perhaps a bit too soft. Pehaps a DOF would have given both the focus and details and that soft feel. ===== From tigerhawk@stic.net: It is a wonderful scene and I really like what you have done since it is very hard to make an image with just one centerpeice. I think you accomplished that goal, but the pixelation of the wood really botheres me. It gives the scene a very false look. But everything else is top notch so nicely done. ===== From a.martone@retepnet.it: As lots of other 3DS images, this also suffers from the "3DStudio syndrome": excessive contrast between textures and textures. The image, rendered at such a high resolution, shows an unrealistic "softened" table. Also, it's not a nice "toys" interpretation. ===== From lefra@voila.fr: nice-looking image, good idea, but the blood doesn't look like blood (not red enough I think) ===== From rgow@lanset.com: Well modelled & textured. A little dark on my monitor. ===== From jacoons@ameritech.net: Points for realism (plus I've seen Jaime's image you refer to). My complaint would be that the wooden floor seems too blurred. ===== From enrique.sahagun@uam.es: you get my best numbers. I love all in your image, the idea, the wooden floor, the blood (perhaps a bit sadistic but consistent with your message), the use of blurring and obvious the light. ===== From jgrimbert@free.fr: That's only one game, or barely a toy. The blood seems too transparent. ===== From fine@head.cfa.harvard.edu: Beautifully detailed, and it communicates it's idea. The leather pouch in the slingshot looks particularly real. What's that blobby thing at the top of the picture? It's nice to see the BBs weren't forgotten when it was time for detail. Blood needs to be look more red and opaque. ===== From jouni@mikrobitti.fi: Very nice composition and concept. Good balance of objects and background. Well done! ===== From p.gibellini@teinos.com: Gruesome... but the woods and the lightning are incredible! Overall is almost photorealistic. ===== From file: Notable for lighting, textures