===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: Some very nice models but the lighting doesn't seem quite right, not = enought shadows I think.. ===== From Andreas.Grates@public.uni-hamburg.de: Nice thing. Wood textures could use more work - I know this kind of wood exists in reality, but even there I think it looks unrealistic. Wood should have some direction of grain. ===== From pbrasolin@yahoo.it: I like very much the lightning on the glass, but I think the shelves could be better: the wood texture reveals your cut'n'paste work. The modeled objects are very nice and particular. ===== From file: Nice composition. A bit too much phong on the old objects. ===== From file: This is good. The only thing I would mention is it looks like a couple of textures have ambient > 1. They mess up the lighting just a bit.