===== From djhouy@paw.za.org: Great idea, and composition--and your stars look way better than mine. There is a lot that could make this image more real and believable, but I think you are well on your way to producing some truly awesome work. ===== From helene.dumur@free.fr: A nice picture, and a good idea too, the tree, perhaps, is quite strange, not very realistic. ===== From irtc@tomandlu.co.uk: Nice modelling on the picnic. ===== From gromit@ix.netcom.com: nice composition and placement of objects. The moons horizon looks too close, although it does not detract from the theme ===== From file: Notable for originality