===== From reinhard.pieper@web.de: Nice idea! :-) The bird is a little bit "out of style". Nice work on the rusted textures. But why is the yellow arm so tidy? Using similar rusted junk on the left side would have imcreased the "junk yard" impression. Notable for textures ===== From aargri@gmail.com: Really nice texture on the crane! The other objects in the scene could use better textures, though. They look out-of-place with the detailed crane texture. Some bump or specular maps would be nice. ===== From tek@evilsuperbrain.com: I like this one, the contrast between the egg and the technology is immediately obvious and very effective. Might be nice for there to be a reason for the egg to be there, i.e. some kind of plot. ===== From RJohnson03@comcast.net: The rust looks magnificent ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Nice concept. The lighting works quite well. The tool looks pretty good. However, the grunge smeared on the tool seems to be a bit to shiny. Your right drum needs a bit more geometry - I can see the ploygons on the top edge. The bird looks like it is at an odd angle... perhaps that needed more realism to match the realism of the scene - or move it further away and add a few more birds. ===== From georgejenner@belgacom.net: I think the arm of the machineis too clean compared to the rest of it, otherwise very nice. ===== From tomvw87@hotmail.com: Good, nice textures. ===== From diegocg@quipo.it: Beautiful image. Nice work with textures. I hope that bird will save his son! ===== From file: Notable for originality, textures ===== From file: nice