INTERNET RAY TRACING COMPETITION Voting form for January-February 2006 This Round's Topic: Fire and Ice ----------------------------------- REGISTRATION ------------ If you have already registered with the IRTC, enter your registration email address and password on the lines below. Make sure to keep the ">>>>> Registration ..." marker on the same line as your information. >>>>> Registration E-Mail Address: >>>>> Registration Password: Votes will be accepted from entrants and panel judges during the period 5 March 2006 through 18 March 2006. Comments are accepted at any time. If you have not yet registered, you may do so either of two ways: 1. Go to "http://www.irtc.org/register.html", the registration WWW page, and follow the instructions. 2. Send an email message to "irtc-vreg@irtc.org" containing a single line in the following format: your_email_address your_password Your email address should be of the form "username@address". Your password is any string you choose. Neither the address nor the password may contain spaces. Separate the address from the password by at least one space. Note that votes will only be accepted from those who entered an image in this round, or from members of the judging panel. See our ftp or web site for information about joining the panel. RATING THE IMAGES ----------------- Please download ALL the images listed below, and view each one before rating it. For each image, give it a rating between 1 and 20 (inclusive) in each of the three listed categories. 1 is the lowest rating, and 20 is the highest. Place each number at the end of its line which starts "Rate image.jpg for ..." IMAGES ------ The images, description files, and source files may be retrieved via ftp from "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/2006-02-28". We encourage you to add comments to the images below, giving your opinions on the images, what you liked, what you didn't like, and so forth. Place your comments between the lines with the ">>>>> Comments on ..." and ">>>>> End Comments on ..." markers. You may enter as many lines as you like. NOTE: your comments will be signed with your voter email address. image: 1volcano.jpg by Tekno Frannansa (243640 bytes) Description: 1volcano.txt Source File: 1volcano.zip Rate 1volcano.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate 1volcano.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate 1volcano.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on 1volcano.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on 1volcano.jpg image: abandon.jpg by Alexandre Dorion (241092 bytes) Description: abandon.txt Source File: abandon.zip Rate abandon.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate abandon.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate abandon.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on abandon.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on abandon.jpg image: adfrost.jpg by Allen Dotson (170775 bytes) Description: adfrost.txt Source File: adfrost.zip Rate adfrost.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate adfrost.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate adfrost.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on adfrost.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on adfrost.jpg image: agbirth.jpg by Florian Siegmund (230561 bytes) Description: agbirth.txt Source File: agbirth.zip Rate agbirth.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate agbirth.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate agbirth.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on agbirth.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on agbirth.jpg image: banquise.jpg by Helene Dumur (90725 bytes) Description: banquise.txt Source File: (none given) Rate banquise.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate banquise.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate banquise.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on banquise.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on banquise.jpg image: candle.jpg by Leroy Whetstone (37573 bytes) Description: candle.txt Source File: candle.zip Rate candle.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate candle.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate candle.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on candle.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on candle.jpg image: candlic1.jpg by Iacopo Mochi (117046 bytes) Description: candlic1.txt Source File: candlic1.zip Rate candlic1.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate candlic1.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate candlic1.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on candlic1.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on candlic1.jpg image: cooking.jpg by J. Grimbert (231611 bytes) Description: cooking.txt Source File: cooking.zip Rate cooking.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate cooking.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate cooking.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on cooking.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on cooking.jpg image: crispfir.jpg by Sarvesh N (104792 bytes) Description: crispfir.txt Source File: (none given) Rate crispfir.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate crispfir.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate crispfir.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on crispfir.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on crispfir.jpg image: dc_diem.jpg by Denis Chassaing (220524 bytes) Description: dc_diem.txt Source File: (none given) Rate dc_diem.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate dc_diem.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate dc_diem.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on dc_diem.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on dc_diem.jpg image: eternal.jpg by Michael Richards (111406 bytes) Description: eternal.txt Source File: (none given) Rate eternal.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate eternal.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate eternal.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on eternal.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on eternal.jpg image: far_sun.jpg by Shigeyoshi M (152329 bytes) Description: far_sun.txt Source File: far_sun.zip Rate far_sun.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate far_sun.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate far_sun.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on far_sun.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on far_sun.jpg image: fire_ice.jpg by Marlo Steed (244744 bytes) Description: fire_ice.txt Source File: (none given) Rate fire_ice.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate fire_ice.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate fire_ice.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on fire_ice.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on fire_ice.jpg image: fireandi.jpg by Jonathan Martinovici (43723 bytes) Description: fireandi.txt Source File: (none given) Rate fireandi.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate fireandi.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate fireandi.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on fireandi.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on fireandi.jpg image: fireflak.jpg by Michael Chelmecki (228091 bytes) Description: fireflak.txt Source File: fireflak.zip Rate fireflak.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate fireflak.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate fireflak.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on fireflak.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on fireflak.jpg image: firelake.jpg by Roman Reiner (249810 bytes) Description: firelake.txt Source File: firelake.zip Rate firelake.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate firelake.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate firelake.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on firelake.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on firelake.jpg image: frznfire.jpg by Robert W. McGregor (246497 bytes) Description: frznfire.txt Source File: (none given) Rate frznfire.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate frznfire.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate frznfire.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on frznfire.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on frznfire.jpg image: hotncold.jpg by Steve Paget (226300 bytes) Description: hotncold.txt Source File: (none given) Rate hotncold.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate hotncold.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate hotncold.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on hotncold.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on hotncold.jpg image: icecup.jpg by Julius Gauckler (142139 bytes) Description: icecup.txt Source File: icecup.zip Rate icecup.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate icecup.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate icecup.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on icecup.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on icecup.jpg image: iceworld.jpg by Peter Hart (63369 bytes) Description: iceworld.txt Source File: (none given) Rate iceworld.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate iceworld.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate iceworld.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on iceworld.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on iceworld.jpg image: lost.jpg by Pierre SCHWARTZ (105532 bytes) Description: lost.txt Source File: (none given) Rate lost.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate lost.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate lost.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on lost.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on lost.jpg image: massage.jpg by Alan Campbell (252046 bytes) Description: massage.txt Source File: massage.zip Rate massage.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate massage.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate massage.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on massage.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on massage.jpg image: moslush.jpg by Mathematical Orchid (248132 bytes) Description: moslush.txt Source File: moslush.zip Rate moslush.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate moslush.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate moslush.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on moslush.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on moslush.jpg image: pawnmelt.jpg by Ian Thornton (180576 bytes) Description: pawnmelt.txt Source File: pawnmelt.zip Rate pawnmelt.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate pawnmelt.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate pawnmelt.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on pawnmelt.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on pawnmelt.jpg image: pianofis.jpg by Jason Knight (247409 bytes) Description: pianofis.txt Source File: pianofis.zip Rate pianofis.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate pianofis.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate pianofis.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on pianofis.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on pianofis.jpg image: pocand.jpg by Paul O'Neill (41230 bytes) Description: pocand.txt Source File: pocand.zip Rate pocand.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate pocand.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate pocand.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on pocand.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on pocand.jpg image: rdgfandi.jpg by Robbert de Groot (169982 bytes) Description: rdgfandi.txt Source File: rdgfandi.zip Rate rdgfandi.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rdgfandi.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rdgfandi.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rdgfandi.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rdgfandi.jpg image: rfhottub.jpg by Rob Fitzel (252858 bytes) Description: rfhottub.txt Source File: (none given) Rate rfhottub.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rfhottub.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rfhottub.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rfhottub.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rfhottub.jpg image: rltalum.jpg by Raphael Ligier Tirilly (28140 bytes) Description: rltalum.txt Source File: (none given) Rate rltalum.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rltalum.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rltalum.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rltalum.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rltalum.jpg image: sl_9.jpg by Timothy Hodge (69704 bytes) Description: sl_9.txt Source File: (none given) Rate sl_9.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate sl_9.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate sl_9.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on sl_9.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on sl_9.jpg image: snowman.jpg by Sean Day (252608 bytes) Description: snowman.txt Source File: snowman.zip Rate snowman.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate snowman.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate snowman.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on snowman.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on snowman.jpg image: sp_fire_.jpg by Stefan Persson (132882 bytes) Description: sp_fire_.txt Source File: (none given) Rate sp_fire_.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate sp_fire_.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate sp_fire_.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on sp_fire_.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on sp_fire_.jpg image: starrise.jpg by Bruno Cabasson (175096 bytes) Description: starrise.txt Source File: starrise.zip Rate starrise.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate starrise.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate starrise.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on starrise.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on starrise.jpg image: temple.jpg by Przemek Dyrczo_ (201614 bytes) Description: temple.txt Source File: (none given) Rate temple.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate temple.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate temple.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on temple.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on temple.jpg image: tequila.jpg by yves lequenne (160997 bytes) Description: tequila.txt Source File: (none given) Rate tequila.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate tequila.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate tequila.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on tequila.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on tequila.jpg image: waterpha.jpg by Gunnar Schroeder (234692 bytes) Description: waterpha.txt Source File: (none given) Rate waterpha.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate waterpha.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate waterpha.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on waterpha.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on waterpha.jpg ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ------------------- If you would like to add comments which are not related to any specific image, place them below, between the lines with the ">>>>>" markers: >>>>> Additional Comments: >>>>> End Additional Comments: SUBMITTING YOUR VOTE -------------------- For your vote to be accepted, you must rate every image in all three categories, except for your own image(s), if you entered this round. Once you have rated the images, and added any comments you might have, either email this form to "irtc-vote@irtc.org", or upload it via anonymous ftp to "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/vote". Votes will be accepted during the period 1 March 2006 through 14 March 2006. You will be notified at your voter email address once your vote has been processed. (Leave these lines alone!) >>>>> Competition subdivision: stills >>>>> Competition Period: 2006-02-28 >>>>> End Form