===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: Who would have thought you could get gore in to a round like this.. I especially like the POV with the pianno/stage being so far down. Great image. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Brutal. This one is tough to look at but I am sure that is what you were going for - it achieves that but is there a way of communicating the message without being so gruesome? ===== From dungbeatle@mail.tds.net: Enjoyed this pic! Felt like it needed more atmosphere. ===== From bigmouth13091@yahoo.com: the best. ===== From raytracing@grayproductions.net: Disturbing, but well crafted. ===== From phenlikescheese@hotmail.com: This is the most creative thing I've ever seen! ===== From file: This image is somewhat problematic for me. Because I oppose censorship on principle, I_m obligated to defend your right as an artist to present it if it expresses an idea or experience that you find genuinely significant. At a purely subjective level however, I must confess I feel that your concerns about the image offending people were justified. ===== From y@yahoo.com: Eww! That's gross. I like it :-) You have a great balance of light and dark here. Unfortunately, I'm not familiar with Cinema 4D enough to provide feedback on the modelling etc, but I gave it high marks because what you've done is VERY hard to do in POVRay, and it looks great. Having the stage below was a bit distracting, especially since it looked like only one tentacle came up, but then lots pierced the musician. Also, the textures on the musician were a bit shiny. Overall, though, a great image! ===== From file: I love the concept of this, although because I have a bit a weak stomach it was a little grousom for me. Great idea though and I love the modelying of the piano keys. Notable for originality, modelling ===== From file: creepy ===== From file: Just a bit macabre. I think the lighting is a bit odd, there don't seem to be enough cast shadows. I also think that there's somewhat of a disconnect created by having such a dark backgroud with such bright shiny metal in the foreground. The images at a distance aren't connected to the rest of the image. It lacks many compositional elements. Well-rendered though. Notable for originality ===== From file: Notable for composition ===== From file: Notable for composition ===== From file: Good thing Notable for originality