===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: This is an excellent image and one of my favourites this round. I love the lighting, the plants/trees look excellent especially the bark texture. The whole image is fantastic!! ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Stunning detail here and I like the way the entire scene is modeled. Your texturees are fairly realistic. I liked the lighting. overall a good picture. Only suggestions would be emphasize the concept of music a it more - not sure what to suggest ... ===== From dungbeatle@mail.tds.net: I love this picture! The violin seems too big. The human model seems stiff and plastic. The peacock looks like a toy. The trees and bushes are great! The lighting is really nice too. he flower growing in the bare part of the path seems out of place. But I love the picture! ===== From 25ct@lineone.net: And again, you capture an image that to me, shows the true artist in yourself. Very nice. Has to be my favourite in this round. ===== From raytracing@grayproductions.net: Pleasant picture. All the pieces are well crafted. ===== From y@yahoo.com: Great work on the tree and grass placement, and the flowers! I tried something similar in my image, so I am very impressed with how you realized this concept. I'm especially impressed with the tree nearest the camera...I need to check your source code for how to do that :-) I did not realize until I read the text file, however, that the flowers and peacock came from the violin. Perhaps adding some media sparkles or something? Or maybe making the violin more the center of focus? I focused on the woman. ===== From file: Nice Job Notable for composition