INTERNET RAY TRACING COMPETITION
                   Comment form for November-December 1998
                     This Round's Topic:  First Encounter
                     ------------------------------------


                                 REGISTRATION
                                 ------------
If you have already registered with the IRTC, enter your registration
email address and password on the lines below.  Make sure to keep the
">>>>> Registration ..." marker on the same line as your information.

>>>>> Registration E-Mail Address:  
>>>>> Registration Password:        


Comments are accepted at any time.

If you have not yet registered, you may do so either of two ways:

1.  Go to "http://www.irtc.org/register.html",
the registration WWW page, and follow the instructions.

2.  Send an email message to "irtc-vreg@irtc.org" containing a
single line in the following format:

   your_email_address  your_password

Your email address should be of the form "username@address".  Your password
is any string you choose.  Neither the address nor the password may contain
spaces.  Separate the address from the password by at least one space.


                                    IMAGES
                                    ------
The images, description files, and source files may be retrieved via ftp from
"ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/1998-12-31".

We encourage you to add comments to the images below, giving your opinions on
the images, what you liked, what you didn't like, and so forth.  Place your
comments between the lines with the ">>>>> Comments on ..." and ">>>>> End
Comments on ..." markers.  You may enter as many lines as you like.  NOTE:
your comments will be signed with your voter email address.

image:    13kitty.jpg by Nathan O'Brien  (112770 bytes)
Description:  13kitty.txt
Source File:  13kitty.zip
>>>>> Comments on 13kitty.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 13kitty.jpg

image:    1_bbang.jpg by Tim Anderson?  (59833 bytes)
Description:  1_bbang.txt
Source File:  1_bbang.zip
>>>>> Comments on 1_bbang.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 1_bbang.jpg

image:    1st_enc.jpg by Bob Franke  (160558 bytes)
Description:  1st_enc.txt
Source File:  1st_enc.zip
>>>>> Comments on 1st_enc.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 1st_enc.jpg

image:    1stmiss.jpg by Grimm  (110833 bytes)
Description:  1stmiss.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on 1stmiss.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 1stmiss.jpg

image:    1stshow.jpg by Paul Vaughan  (117167 bytes)
Description:  1stshow.txt
Source File:  1stshow.zip
>>>>> Comments on 1stshow.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 1stshow.jpg

image:    2010.jpg by Harald Schoenknecht  (117416 bytes)
Description:  2010.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on 2010.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 2010.jpg

image:    86c_pi.jpg by Matthias Opitz  (103134 bytes)
Description:  86c_pi.txt
Source File:  86c_pi.zip
>>>>> Comments on 86c_pi.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 86c_pi.jpg

image:    8_forgiv.jpg by Tim Stratton  (71532 bytes)
Description:  8_forgiv.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on 8_forgiv.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 8_forgiv.jpg

image:    8_weding.jpg by Lance Bellavance  (64033 bytes)
Description:  8_weding.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on 8_weding.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 8_weding.jpg

image:    9_doors.jpg by Tim Anderson?  (79623 bytes)
Description:  9_doors.txt
Source File:  9_doors.zip
>>>>> Comments on 9_doors.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on 9_doors.jpg

image:    ac_vs_eb.jpg by H. E. Day (Howard Earl)  (157515 bytes)
Description:  ac_vs_eb.txt
Source File:  ac_vs_eb.zip
>>>>> Comments on ac_vs_eb.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on ac_vs_eb.jpg

image:    afrog.jpg by OLLIVIER DE LANGLAIS  (158885 bytes)
Description:  afrog.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on afrog.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on afrog.jpg

image:    alien20w.jpg by Roy Scott  (190428 bytes)
Description:  alien20w.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on alien20w.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on alien20w.jpg

image:    amanecer.jpg by Txemi Jendrix (J. M. Gonzalez-Pinto)  (139224 bytes)
Description:  amanecer.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on amanecer.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on amanecer.jpg

image:    benshock.jpg by Benjamin Kniaz  (194796 bytes)
Description:  benshock.txt
Source File:  benshock.zip
>>>>> Comments on benshock.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on benshock.jpg

image:    blinddat.jpg by Frank Epple  (242211 bytes)
Description:  blinddat.txt
Source File:  blinddat.zip
>>>>> Comments on blinddat.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on blinddat.jpg

image:    bogeys.jpg by Dave Merchant  (212652 bytes)
Description:  bogeys.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on bogeys.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on bogeys.jpg

image:    byop.jpg by Blaine Holmes  (157710 bytes)
Description:  byop.txt
Source File:  byop.zip
>>>>> Comments on byop.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on byop.jpg

image:    cbh_fe.jpg by Chris Hernandez  (139525 bytes)
Description:  cbh_fe.txt
Source File:  cbh_fe.zip
>>>>> Comments on cbh_fe.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on cbh_fe.jpg

image:    ceotsk.jpg by Phillip L. Easton  (244237 bytes)
Description:  ceotsk.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on ceotsk.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on ceotsk.jpg

image:    cjmem.jpg by Christof Joswig  (161145 bytes)
Description:  cjmem.txt
Source File:  cjmem.zip
>>>>> Comments on cjmem.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on cjmem.jpg

image:    cosdblit.jpg by Tim Glover  (41681 bytes)
Description:  cosdblit.txt
Source File:  cosdblit.zip
>>>>> Comments on cosdblit.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on cosdblit.jpg

image:    coverup.jpg by John K. Dewhurst  (231381 bytes)
Description:  coverup.txt
Source File:  coverup.zip
>>>>> Comments on coverup.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on coverup.jpg

image:    cow.jpg by Joey Mendoza  (27882 bytes)
Description:  cow.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on cow.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on cow.jpg

image:    d_magic3.jpg by Tim Anderson?  (61682 bytes)
Description:  d_magic3.txt
Source File:  d_magic3.zip
>>>>> Comments on d_magic3.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on d_magic3.jpg

image:    dbwtribu.jpg by Joel NewKirk  (191239 bytes)
Description:  dbwtribu.txt
Source File:  dbwtribu.zip
>>>>> Comments on dbwtribu.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on dbwtribu.jpg

image:    distvoy.jpg by David Ray  (138402 bytes)
Description:  distvoy.txt
Source File:  distvoy.zip
>>>>> Comments on distvoy.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on distvoy.jpg

image:    dpcgiant.jpg by Daniel Pagan Connell  (139265 bytes)
Description:  dpcgiant.txt
Source File:  dpcgiant.zip
>>>>> Comments on dpcgiant.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on dpcgiant.jpg

image:    echiquie.jpg by Anne MONTI  (111906 bytes)
Description:  echiquie.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on echiquie.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on echiquie.jpg

image:    el_love.jpg by Alberto Campione  (91290 bytes)
Description:  el_love.txt
Source File:  el_love.zip
>>>>> Comments on el_love.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on el_love.jpg

image:    encuen.jpg by OMAR LOPEZ  (230251 bytes)
Description:  encuen.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on encuen.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on encuen.jpg

image:    evening2.jpg by Bill Pragnell  (53907 bytes)
Description:  evening2.txt
Source File:  evening2.zip
>>>>> Comments on evening2.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on evening2.jpg

image:    exhibit.jpg by Stephen Lumini  (224385 bytes)
Description:  exhibit.txt
Source File:  exhibit.zip
>>>>> Comments on exhibit.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on exhibit.jpg

image:    fab_fe1.jpg by Fabien Villard  (117567 bytes)
Description:  fab_fe1.txt
Source File:  fab_fe1.zip
>>>>> Comments on fab_fe1.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on fab_fe1.jpg

image:    first3d.jpg by Bruce Johnson  (223269 bytes)
Description:  first3d.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on first3d.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on first3d.jpg

image:    firstxli.jpg by Devon Zachary  (95389 bytes)
Description:  firstxli.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on firstxli.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on firstxli.jpg

image:    fm_moon.jpg by Fred Mosby  (65345 bytes)
Description:  fm_moon.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on fm_moon.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on fm_moon.jpg

image:    fmenc.jpg by Fabien MOSEN  (125706 bytes)
Description:  fmenc.txt
Source File:  fmenc.zip
>>>>> Comments on fmenc.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on fmenc.jpg

image:    food101.jpg by Dale E. Cieslak  (215883 bytes)
Description:  food101.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on food101.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on food101.jpg

image:    ge_first.jpg by Guillermo Espitia Rojas  (235653 bytes)
Description:  ge_first.txt
Source File:  ge_first.zip
>>>>> Comments on ge_first.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on ge_first.jpg

image:    greeting.jpg by Claude GUILLEMOT  (217589 bytes)
Description:  greeting.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on greeting.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on greeting.jpg

image:    idbnf6b.jpg by Ian Brunton  (67104 bytes)
Description:  idbnf6b.txt
Source File:  idbnf6b.zip
>>>>> Comments on idbnf6b.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on idbnf6b.jpg

image:    ilovyou2.jpg by Martial  (70255 bytes)
Description:  ilovyou2.txt
Source File:  ilovyou2.zip
>>>>> Comments on ilovyou2.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on ilovyou2.jpg

image:    isfirste.jpg by Ian Shumsky  (208604 bytes)
Description:  isfirste.txt
Source File:  isfirste.zip
>>>>> Comments on isfirste.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on isfirste.jpg

image:    jbshow.jpg by Jerome BERGER  (137263 bytes)
Description:  jbshow.txt
Source File:  jbshow.zip
>>>>> Comments on jbshow.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on jbshow.jpg

image:    koluvian.jpg by Benjamin Jackson  (201212 bytes)
Description:  koluvian.txt
Source File:  koluvian.zip
>>>>> Comments on koluvian.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on koluvian.jpg

image:    landing.jpg by Ian & Ethel MacKay  (215158 bytes)
Description:  landing.txt
Source File:  landing.zip
>>>>> Comments on landing.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on landing.jpg

image:    life.jpg by Caleb Hattingh  (195133 bytes)
Description:  life.txt
Source File:  life.zip
>>>>> Comments on life.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on life.jpg

image:    lostcity.jpg by Marc Schimmler  (179569 bytes)
Description:  lostcity.txt
Source File:  lostcity.zip
>>>>> Comments on lostcity.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on lostcity.jpg

image:    magic.jpg by Johnny Yip  (98061 bytes)
Description:  magic.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on magic.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on magic.jpg

image:    maker.jpg by Jeff Albert  (221142 bytes)
Description:  maker.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on maker.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on maker.jpg

image:    married.jpg by Rene Novak  (165222 bytes)
Description:  married.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on married.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on married.jpg

image:    mars2.jpg by Simon de Vet  (149233 bytes)
Description:  mars2.txt
Source File:  mars2.zip
>>>>> Comments on mars2.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on mars2.jpg

image:    martian.jpg by Chris Bunker  (170457 bytes)
Description:  martian.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on martian.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on martian.jpg

image:    meteor01.jpg by Zi En  (173316 bytes)
Description:  meteor01.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on meteor01.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on meteor01.jpg

image:    mg_rose.jpg by Marjorie Diez de Graterol  (105103 bytes)
Description:  mg_rose.txt
Source File:  mg_rose.zip
>>>>> Comments on mg_rose.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on mg_rose.jpg

image:    ml_arriv.jpg by Marius Liebenberg  (91742 bytes)
Description:  ml_arriv.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on ml_arriv.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on ml_arriv.jpg

image:    moonjaws.jpg by Mike Robertson  (236604 bytes)
Description:  moonjaws.txt
Source File:  moonjaws.zip
>>>>> Comments on moonjaws.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on moonjaws.jpg

image:    narcisus.jpg by Thomas Nelson  (98928 bytes)
Description:  narcisus.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on narcisus.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on narcisus.jpg

image:    nest.jpg by Jeremy Gregoire  (78248 bytes)
Description:  nest.txt
Source File:  nest.zip
>>>>> Comments on nest.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on nest.jpg

image:    newmoney.jpg by Heather Cousineau  (94479 bytes)
Description:  newmoney.txt
Source File:  newmoney.zip
>>>>> Comments on newmoney.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on newmoney.jpg

image:    newvenus.jpg by David Nash  (204633 bytes)
Description:  newvenus.txt
Source File:  newvenus.zip
>>>>> Comments on newvenus.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on newvenus.jpg

image:    nppolar.jpg by Nicholas W. Porter  (254315 bytes)
Description:  nppolar.txt
Source File:  nppolar.zip
>>>>> Comments on nppolar.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on nppolar.jpg

image:    oh.jpg by Birgit Jauernig  (143974 bytes)
Description:  oh.txt
Source File:  oh.zip
>>>>> Comments on oh.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on oh.jpg

image:    orion7.jpg by Jens Dengler  (223132 bytes)
Description:  orion7.txt
Source File:  orion7.zip
>>>>> Comments on orion7.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on orion7.jpg

image:    plugin.jpg by Andre Mecteau  (71858 bytes)
Description:  plugin.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on plugin.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on plugin.jpg

image:    pool.jpg by Marco Bucci  (213770 bytes)
Description:  pool.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on pool.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on pool.jpg

image:    pvcman.jpg by Greg M. Johnson  (226520 bytes)
Description:  pvcman.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on pvcman.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on pvcman.jpg

image:    rasconqu.jpg by Raymond A. Salvatore  (214857 bytes)
Description:  rasconqu.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on rasconqu.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on rasconqu.jpg

image:    roach.jpg by Jeffrey Anderson  (89436 bytes)
Description:  roach.txt
Source File:  roach.zip
>>>>> Comments on roach.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on roach.jpg

image:    robot.jpg by Hannes Rohde  (208797 bytes)
Description:  robot.txt
Source File:  robot.zip
>>>>> Comments on robot.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on robot.jpg

image:    samaro.jpg by shimon  (88046 bytes)
Description:  samaro.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on samaro.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on samaro.jpg

image:    sf_bony.jpg by Sammy Fischer  (84003 bytes)
Description:  sf_bony.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on sf_bony.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on sf_bony.jpg

image:    sillykit.jpg by Discord  (103925 bytes)
Description:  sillykit.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on sillykit.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on sillykit.jpg

image:    snowmen.jpg by Paxton Provitera  (196355 bytes)
Description:  snowmen.txt
Source File:  snowmen.zip
>>>>> Comments on snowmen.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on snowmen.jpg

image:    snowy.jpg by Damien Verhelst  (172140 bytes)
Description:  snowy.txt
Source File:  snowy.zip
>>>>> Comments on snowy.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on snowy.jpg

image:    spider.jpg by Torsten Schneyer  (61483 bytes)
Description:  spider.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on spider.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on spider.jpg

image:    stonegod.jpg by Karl Manning  (100779 bytes)
Description:  stonegod.txt
Source File:  stonegod.zip
>>>>> Comments on stonegod.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on stonegod.jpg

image:    strike.jpg by N.B. (beliaev@utu.fi) and Glenn McCarter (gmccarter@hotmail.com)  (198625 bytes)
Description:  strike.txt
Source File:  strike.zip
>>>>> Comments on strike.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on strike.jpg

image:    surveil.jpg by Stephen Lumini  (222907 bytes)
Description:  surveil.txt
Source File:  surveil.zip
>>>>> Comments on surveil.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on surveil.jpg

image:    survey.jpg by Dave Merchant  (184380 bytes)
Description:  survey.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on survey.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on survey.jpg

image:    svoyager.jpg by Steve Attwood  (112528 bytes)
Description:  svoyager.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on svoyager.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on svoyager.jpg

image:    tbenc01.jpg by Toni Bratincevic  (198019 bytes)
Description:  tbenc01.txt
Source File:  tbenc01.zip
>>>>> Comments on tbenc01.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on tbenc01.jpg

image:    the20fir.jpg by Sasha Sapojnikoff  (29612 bytes)
Description:  the20fir.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on the20fir.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on the20fir.jpg

image:    the20oth.jpg by Sasha Sapojnikoff  (101484 bytes)
Description:  the20oth.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on the20oth.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on the20oth.jpg

image:    the_napk.jpg by Sean Hamilton  (171427 bytes)
Description:  the_napk.txt
Source File:  the_napk.zip
>>>>> Comments on the_napk.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on the_napk.jpg

image:    tkamb.jpg by Russell Garwood and Justin Greer  (230715 bytes)
Description:  tkamb.txt
Source File:  tkamb.zip
>>>>> Comments on tkamb.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on tkamb.jpg

image:    vicalien.jpg by Victor Widell  (149218 bytes)
Description:  vicalien.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on vicalien.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on vicalien.jpg

image:    violet.jpg by Sergei Shuvalkin  (236850 bytes)
Description:  violet.txt
Source File:  violet.zip
>>>>> Comments on violet.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on violet.jpg

image:    wheel.jpg by MIKE CHERRY  (120435 bytes)
Description:  wheel.txt
Source File:  wheel.zip
>>>>> Comments on wheel.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on wheel.jpg

image:    x1mach1.jpg by Dave Hamilton  (174022 bytes)
Description:  x1mach1.txt
Source File:  x1mach1.zip
>>>>> Comments on x1mach1.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on x1mach1.jpg

image:    xa2004.jpg by Matthew Corey Brown  (82437 bytes)
Description:  xa2004.txt
Source File:  (none given)
>>>>> Comments on xa2004.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on xa2004.jpg

image:    xwing.jpg by Roland Vansteenkiste  (252186 bytes)
Description:  xwing.txt
Source File:  xwing.zip
>>>>> Comments on xwing.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on xwing.jpg

image:    zship.jpg by Patrick Dugan  (71892 bytes)
Description:  zship.txt
Source File:  zship.zip
>>>>> Comments on zship.jpg:
>>>>> End Comments on zship.jpg


                             ADDITIONAL COMMENTS
                             -------------------
If you would like to add comments which are not related to any specific image,
place them below, between the lines with the ">>>>>" markers:

>>>>> Additional Comments:
>>>>> End Additional Comments:

Once you have entered any comments you might have, either
email this form to "irtc-comm@irtc.org", or upload it via
anonymous ftp to "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/vote".

(Leave these lines alone!)
>>>>> Competition subdivision: stills
>>>>> Competition Period:  1998-12-31
>>>>> End Form